How to Ship TCGplayer Cards with 4x6 Labels and Kraft Envelopes

Why This Workflow Works for TCGplayer Sellers

Selling trading cards on TCGplayer means shipping a lot of small, high-value items. Speed matters, but so does protecting the cards. This guide walks you through a reliable system using 4.25 x 6.25 inch brown kraft envelopes and 4x6 printed shipping labels created with My Shipping Label.

What You Need

Step 1: Protect the Card

Never ship a raw card in just an envelope. Cards can bend, crease, or get damaged in transit.

Pro tip: Use painter's tape (blue tape) instead of scotch tape. It peels off cleanly without leaving residue or damaging the top-loader. Your buyer will appreciate it.

Step 2: Prepare the Envelope

Take a 4.25 x 6.25 inch kraft envelope. These are the ideal size because:

Optional extra protection: Cut a small piece of cardboard (like from a cereal box) to the size of the envelope. Place it behind the top-loader inside the envelope for extra rigidity. This is especially worth doing for cards over $10 in value.

Step 3: Pack the Envelope

The card should fit snugly without moving around. Give the sealed envelope a gentle shake to confirm nothing shifts.

Step 4: Print Your Label

If you're using a thermal printer, load a 4x6 thermal label and print directly. If you're using an inkjet, print on adhesive label paper and peel-and-stick.

Step 5: Ship It

Drop the labeled envelope at your mailbox or post office. For standard TCGplayer orders under $20, USPS First Class Mail with tracking is the standard. The envelope is lightweight enough to stay under 1 oz in most cases.

Quick Reference: Packing Checklist

Why Printed Labels Matter for TCGplayer

Handwritten labels work, but printed labels:

TCGplayer buyers rate sellers on shipping speed and packaging quality. A clean, printed label signals that you take your business seriously.

Recommended Supplies